MUIR — More than 175 people gathered Saturday near the site of a former mine in Porter Township where nine men died in March 1977, and they dedicated a sign recognizing the history of the event, the “Porter Tunnel Mine Disaster.”
“It’s three foot by five foot. It’s made of aluminum and the frame is made of wood,” said Beth Harman, Valley View, daughter of one of those miners, Dennis L. Morgan. She came up with the idea for the sign.
“I knew we were coming up on the 40th anniversary and I felt that something should have been done. I wasn’t emotionally ready to open up old wounds and I think that’s why nothing has been done in the past. Who wants to remember something horrible that had happened? But I want future generations to remember what happened and to remember how dangerous coal mining was back then. We installed it back in the fall because I didn’t expect it to be 70 degrees in February,” Harman said Saturday.
With yellow and white words on a black background, the sign offers a brief history of the event and the names of the nine men who died.
It’s on the south side of Route 209, between Muir and Joliett, at the former entrance to the mine on property owned by Rausch Creek Land LP, Valley View, according to the online Schuylkill Parcel Locator.
At the dedication Saturday, state Rep. Mike Tobash, R-125, and state Sen. David G. Argall, R-29, said they’re making an effort to have a state historical marker placed on the site.
“On March 13, I’m going to be in the House of Representatives. I’m going to offer a resolution. I invite you all to come. It’s going to be on the state record. Senator Argall and I are working on making sure we get a state marker that would be on the highway here so that people, forever, when they drive by this location understand the tragedy that happened here,” Tobash said.
“I further challenge all of us to commit on this day to seek the approval of the PA State Historical Commission to formally recognize this event as a historical event and seek an official PA State Historical Marker to mark it for eternity so that future generations always remember what happened here,” Tower City Mayor Dan Daub said in a proclamation recognizing the miners.
History
The incident occurred at the Kocher Coal Co. Porter Tunnel Mine at 11:50 a.m. Tuesday, March 1, 1977.
Tons of impounded water flooded the West Skidmore South Dip conveyor gangway.
“The thing about water is you can’t run from it. You can’t hide from it. Water is a deadly killer whether you’re inside the coal mine or outside,” said David A. Lucas, Hegins, who was at Saturday’s event. He’s a retired coal miner known in the community for organizing the annual Independent Bootleggers’ Coal Miners Picnic at Hegins Park.
The flooding caused the death of nine miners.
They were Gary L. Klinger, Hegins; Mark Kroh, Good Spring; Timothy L. Grose, Ashland; Philip Sabatino, Hegins; John Moyer, Ashland; Ronald R. Herb, Valley View; Dennis L. Morgan, Valley View; Donald E. Shoffler, Gordon; and Ralph Renninger, Donaldson, according to Harman and the newspaper’s archives.
Sabatino was 50 when he died.
His wife, Pearl, was 49 at the time. She is 89 now and was at Saturday’s event with her daughter, Sharon Erdman, Hegins, and Sharon’s daughter, Tammy Erdman, Hegins.
“They found him on the first day, but they didn’t bring him out until the second day,” Sharon Erdman said.
“I’ll always remember that day because that was my seventh birthday,” Tammy Erdman, who turned 7 on March 2, 1977, said.
“He was a hard worker. He’d work in the mine during the day then he’d come home and farm. He was funny, very generous. He helped everyone,” Sharon Erdman said of her father.
“I was told he had gotten out of the mine then went back in. He went back in to help more people, but he didn’t get out the second time,” Tammy Erdman said.
Dennis Lee Morgan was 30 when he died.
“He was very hardworking,” Harman said of her father.
“I remember him playing a bass guitar. He played in a band. I think it was called The Country Rocks. He played with his uncle, Clayton, who was also a coal miner. And he also played bass guitar at the Foursquare Church in Muir,” she said Friday.
In March 1977, she was 11 and a student at Hegins-Hubley Elementary School.
“I was at school at that time. I remember coming home and coming into the kitchen and that’s when my mom told me what happened,” she said.
Her mother was Barbara Herb Morgan, who died in 1993. The family also included two other children, Donald and Cathy.
“Mom said there was an accident and they were trying to find him. But they couldn’t find him. And for 28 days I was hopeful,” Harman said.
On March 28, 1977, the remains of her father were found in the tunnel.
Following his funeral, Dennis Morgan was buried at Trinity Lutheran Cemetery, which is behind St. Andrew’s Church in Valley View. His date of death is listed as March 1, 1977.
When the accident occurred on March 1, 1977, another miner, Ronald Adley, Tower City, became trapped inside Big Lick Mountain. He was stuck there for 122 hours, which is five days and two hours. Rescue crews tunneled through a 50-foot wall of coal to free Adley, according to the archives.
At the time, it was the worst mine disaster in the anthracite region since Jan. 22, 1959, when the Susquehanna River broke through the Knox Coal Co. mine at Port Griffith, killing 12 men, according to the archives.
“Since then, the mine has been filled in. It had been filled in 10 years ago. There’s nothing there to see now but a pipe where water comes out, ironically,” Harman said.
Memories
Timothy Grose was 19 when he died. His body was recovered from the mine on March 29, 1977, according to the sign dedicated Saturday.
His sister, Debra Demboski, Ashland, was there Saturday holding a framed picture of him. It was taken when he graduated from Tri-Valley High School in 1975.
“I think this is wonderful to finally be able to memorialize all these men that were lost,” Demboski said.
“This is a wonderful thing to have in memory and in honor of these coal miners,” Lucas said.
One of the miners who survived the March 1, 1977, flooding at the mine, John Morgan, Tower City — a cousin of Dennis Morgan — was also at the event Saturday.
He was 33 at the time of the flood.
Now, John Morgan resides in Muir.
“He’ll be 74 in June. He was stuck in here. The water had come up over his head and he passed out. And he said that he and Ernie, when they were in there, they looked at each other and said, ‘Well, I guess this is it,’ ” John Morgan’s granddaughter, Pam Miller, said.
John Morgan managed to crawl up an air shaft after the mine was flooded. He was taken to the former Pottsville Hospital for treatment, according to the newspaper’s archives.
Miller was referring to Ernest R. Morgan, Valley View, who also survived the flooding.
Argall presented a wooden plaque, a Certificate of Remembrance from the Senate of Pennsylvania.
“We need to find a central locale so everybody can see that. That’s something we’re working on,” Harman said.
It included the following statement: “While coal mining has deep roots in this area and contributes significantly to our area’s economy, it comes with great risks — as evidenced by the Porter Tunnel Mine Disaster. May we never forget the men who lost their lives in that incident, or the emergency workers, relatives and residents who aided in recovery efforts, saving lives in the process.”
Speakers at Saturday’s event included the Rev. Carl D. Shankweiler, secretary of the Northeastern Pennsylvania Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America.
“Although I’m from Valley View, I wasn’t living in this area at that time. Forty years ago, I was down in Berks County. But we certainly knew what was taking place here at this tunnel. It was national news,” Shankweiler told the crowd.
“This news was an event that had an effect on our community. One of those who died, Dennis Morgan, was a classmate of mine. His wife was also a classmate of mine,” Shankweiler said.
“To lose a classmate is one thing. But the families involved, it was losing a father, a son, a brother, an uncle. It becomes much, much more personal. So for my friend, Barbara Herb, it was the loss of a husband. For her children, it was the loss of a father. For everyone who died there’s a similar story of family that was changed forever,” Shankweiler said.
Other local dignitaries, including Schuylkill County Commissioner Gary Hess and William Schaeffer, a supervisor with Porter Township, presented proclamations. One of the trustees of the Tremont Area Historical Society, Perry Pillar, said a few words.
“We may not have the same blood running through our veins, we may not have the same names, but we’re one family in the coal region. I want you to take that with you. Be proud of your heritage,” Pillar said.
The sign dedicated Saturday was made by a group of volunteers, Harman said.
They included representatives of Felty Custom Graphics, Fort Ashby, West Virginia.
“That’s actually my nephew. His name is Dennis Felty. He was named after my father,” Harman said.
Others included Dennis and Cathy Felty, West Virginia; Jeff and Nick Harman, Valley View; Katie Schroding, New Philadelphia; Jeff Harman Jr., Mountville, Lancaster County; and Mark and Clair Harman, Hegins.
Following the dedication, there was a reception at St. Andrew’s United Methodist Church in Valley View.