Pennsylvania’s U.S. Senate race will pit two brand names against each other.
Robert P. Casey Jr. — Sen. Bob Casey everywhere but on the election ballot — carries a Democratic political brand name established decades ago by his father, the late Gov. Robert P. Casey Sr.
Casey’s opponent, U.S. Rep. Lou Barletta, a Republican well-known locally, lacks a similar statewide brand name, but he can count on the help of a man who’s an actual brand: Donald Trump. The Republican president’s name has adorned a wide variety of investments, some as small as a belt buckle.
The Senate contest between Casey, 58, of Scranton, and Barletta, 62, of Hazleton, undoubtedly will center on Trump, Barletta’s close connection to the president, and whether Casey can turn it to his advantage.
“He, more than any other candidate I can think of, will rise and fall with President Trump’s standing,” said Christopher Borick, Ph.D., Muhlenberg College pollster and longtime state politics analyst. “He is absolutely tethered to the president..
A popular Trump by November improves Barletta’s chances; an unpopular one ends them.
“I could see Casey still winning even if the president has a moderate resurgence simply because he’s not an easy mark for Republicans,” Borick said.
Both earn $174,000 a year, and will if elected to the Senate.
In his first Senate run, Casey fastened an unpopular political brand name, President George W. Bush, to incumbent Republican Sen. Rick Santorum and won by 17 percentage points, a rout unusual in a state known for close elections.
Casey, who won re-election in 2012, doesn’t dispute Trump’s role in this, his third run for Senate, and expects “a tough race against a tough opponent in a very difficult state.”
“We’ve got a state that is not blue or red, it’s purple,” he said. “That means depending on the year, it could tilt either way.”
As one of Trump’s first congressional supporters, Barletta welcomes efforts to paint him into Trump’s corner. In an interview, the congressman, once owner of a successful highway line-painting business, practically offered Casey the paint. Not only does he expect Trump to campaign for him, he will welcome the help, he said. Santorum distanced himself from Bush.
“There’s no way I’m going to apologize for his policies or his agenda that have the economy soaring, people feeling very confident again, wages rising, ISIS just about gone, North Korea coming to the table, the wall’s being built (on the Mexican border), unemployment’s at 3.9 percent, the stock market’s (up) over 20 percent, black unemployment’s at an all-time low, Hispanic unemployment’s at an all-time low,” Barletta said. “What’s there to apologize for?”
Two well-known Northeast Pennsylvanians have faced each other for a major statewide office before. In 1986, the senator’s father faced Lt. Gov. William W. Scranton III, the son of former Gov. William W. Scranton Jr., a staunch Republican who embodied the word “moderate.”
Barletta considers himself a moderate, but Democrats have deemed him a radical for years, starting with his crusade as Hazleton mayor against illegal immigration that brought him national acclaim and condemnation.
Barletta loves to talk about the December 2005 day that he sought help combatting illegal immigration in a meeting in Washington with Justice Department officials, who listened politely, handed him a keepsake coffee mug, patted his back and never did a thing.
A few months later, an immigrant living in the country illegally killed a Hazleton resident and Barletta pushed through city laws targeting businesses who hire immigrants who enter the country illegally and landlords who rent to them. Federal courts struck down the laws, leaving Hazleton with a massive legal bill. On his third try, voters elected Barletta to Congress over a 26-year incumbent Democrat, Rep. Paul Kanjorski, Nanticoke.
Barletta said Casey does nothing but obstruct the president’s agenda. The senator voted against the Trump-backed tax cut that Republicans say put an average of $1,000 in the pockets of more than 90 percent of Americans, he said. Casey also backed the Affordable Care Act, known as Obamacare, that Barletta and Republicans blame for raising health insurance premiums.
Unlike Casey, the fourth-term congressman said, he has gotten things done. He has pushed policies that saved $3.7 billion on federal building leases; fought for money-saving public-private partnerships for other federal offices; supported an after-school program that targets troubled students and fought to restore federal funding for after-school programs; and fought to revamp programs meant to mitigate disasters before they happen.
He said he remains a leading voice against illegal immigration and for protecting animals.
“I don’t know what he’s done,” Barletta said of Casey. “Most people tell me they can’t name anything he’s done.”
Casey’s campaign produces a long list of accomplishments over his first two terms. The senator highlights four — a law that allows tax breaks for Americans with disabilities who save for future care expenses; another that requires uniform reporting of college sexual assaults; a law that secured permanent health care benefits for almost 2,000 retired Pennsylvania coal miners; and money to deepen the Delaware River, for which he lobbied President Barack Obama.
He says Barletta gives Trump credit for an economic boom that started with Democrats passing a recovery law that cut unemployment in half under Obama.
While Barletta says he’s a “blue-collar worker ... mayor ... congressman,” Casey describes himself as the defender of the middle class, whose wages have grown minimally over the last 40 years.
Barletta boasts about voting to repeal Obamacare “61 times” and blames the law for higher premiums. Casey said Republicans’ zeal to repeal displays a willingness to kill a law that forbids discrimination against people with pre-existing conditions, keeps children on parents’ health insurance plans until age 26, cuts senior citizens’ prescription drug costs and produces health insurance for 20 million Americans who never had it before.
“Health care is going to be a major part of the debate,” he said.
Barletta portrays Casey as an obstructionist to Trump’s agenda, but Casey points out he and the president agree on rejecting a Far East trade deal, a tougher trade deal with China and renegotiating the North American Free Trade Agreement.
Casey said he’s the one who will stand up to the president instead of believing the president can do no wrong.
“We’re going to have a nation that either is going to stand up for American workers or we’re going to keep these giveaways for special interests,” Casey said.
Contact the writer: bkrawczeniuk@timesshamrock.com; 570-348-9147